by thrustbucket
I can't speak for James but I agree with him. The reason being that everything in this game follows logic. One of the nice things about this game is when you have a question bout the rules you just imagine you are really a mage in a fight and you will usually find the right answer.A dead creature or person can not counter strike (which is an attack right after he's attacked). A damage shield hurts the aggressor as he's attacking.
Just use your imagination and the rules spell out themselves.