Reply: Mage Wars:: Rules:: Re: Chain lightning and Divine Intervention
by curtcGus_Sin wrote:1) Is it legal to reveal DI when I did? I don't think so. Rules say, "You cannot interrupt an event to reveal an enchantment."
View ArticleReply: Mage Wars:: General:: Re: Spray paint Mod to second marker set
by ghbell Those look cool. The Quickcast symbol you have there, did you print that on paper? What is it printed on?
View ArticleReply: Mage Wars:: Rules:: Re: Chain lightning and Divine Intervention
by Gus_Sincurtc wrote:I don't think so. Rules say, "You cannot interrupt an event to reveal an enchantment."That's what I though at first, but the rules also say you can reveal "At the end of any of...
View ArticleReply: Mage Wars:: Rules:: Re: Chain lightning and Divine Intervention
by Mike1977curtc wrote:Gus_Sin wrote:1) Is it legal to reveal DI when I did? I don't think so. Rules say, "You cannot interrupt an event to reveal an enchantment."I'm pretty sure its legal... Chain...
View ArticleReply: Mage Wars:: Rules:: Re: Chain lightning and Divine Intervention
by curtcGus_Sin wrote:I'm asking because they always say they want the game to work the way you would expect things to happen and in this case I would expect DI to activate :) You don't expect...
View ArticleReply: Mage Wars:: Rules:: Re: Chain lightning and Divine Intervention
by Mike1977curtc wrote:Gus_Sin wrote:I'm asking because they always say they want the game to work the way you would expect things to happen and in this case I would expect DI to activate :) You don't...
View ArticleReply: Mage Wars:: Rules:: Re: Chain lightning and Divine Intervention
by Gus_SinIf there were an explicit Declare Attack phase (which gives you right to reveal enchantment), then the rules for that phase are applied, which say, "If you discover that you cannot legally...
View ArticleReply: Mage Wars:: Rules:: Re: Chain lightning and Divine Intervention
by Gus_SinI get the impression that rule applies only if the active creature accidently targets someting that he cannot target.Human error so to speak.Ah I think you might be right about that (it's in...
View ArticleReply: Mage Wars:: Rules:: Re: Chain lightning and Divine Intervention
by Mike1977Gus_Sin wrote:I get the impression that rule applies only if the active creature accidently targets someting that he cannot target.Human error so to speak.Ah I think you might be right about...
View ArticleReply: Mage Wars:: Rules:: Re: Chain lightning and Divine Intervention
by curtc Except that the spell has already been cast. It's not countered. If the claim is that an enchantment can be revealed because it's after the 1st phase of combat, then the rules for that phase...
View ArticleReply: Mage Wars:: Rules:: Re: Chain lightning and Divine Intervention
by Gus_Sincurtc wrote:Except that the spell has already been cast. It's not countered. If the claim is that an enchantment can be revealed because it's after the 1st phase of combat, then the rules for...
View ArticleReply: Mage Wars:: Rules:: Re: Chain lightning and Divine Intervention
by Mike1977 If Chain Lightning is cast, and the target DI's out of range, then yeah the spell would be countered...BUT...If you target a creature and deal damage to him, then target another creature,...
View ArticleReply: Mage Wars:: Rules:: Re: Chain lightning and Divine Intervention
by Gus_Sin You should remember that CL is cast on the first creature ONLY. After that it's CL doing it's attack. So once it's successfully cast on the first target then there is no more occasion for it...
View ArticleReply: Mage Wars:: Rules:: Re: Chain lightning and Divine Intervention
by Mike1977Gus_Sin wrote:You should remember that CL is cast on the first creature ONLY. After that it's CL doing it's attack. So once it's successfully cast on the first target then there is no more...
View ArticleReply: Mage Wars:: Rules:: Re: Chain lightning and Divine Intervention
by Gus_Sin The teleport happens after one of the attack phases. So It can not happen before the 'Declare Attack' phase which means the creature becomes the target of the attack. I haven't seen anything...
View ArticleReply: Mage Wars:: Rules:: Re: Chain lightning and Divine Intervention
by curtc It definitely can't be the case that you teleport away and take damage. That clearly doesn't make sense. I think we need to first be clear on whether the reveal is legal, and if so, why. What...
View ArticleReply: Mage Wars:: Rules:: Re: Chain lightning and Divine Intervention
by Gus_Sincurtc wrote:It definitely can't be the case that you teleport away and take damage. That clearly doesn't make sense. I think we need to first be clear on whether the reveal is legal, and if...
View ArticleClik here to view.
Reply: Mage Wars:: Rules:: Re: Chain lightning and Divine Intervention
by curtcGus_Sin wrote:Since it says "may attack another target" I understand there is a second attack which would have to have a declare attack phase and if that's the case then there is nothing to...
View ArticleReply: Mage Wars:: Rules:: Re: Chain lightning and Divine Intervention
by Gus_Sincurtc wrote:Agreed, but then I also don't see why the rules in declare attack phase wouldn't apply.Sorry I didn't quite get this. Which rules in declare attack phase?
View Article